Current:Home > MarketsWisconsin appeals court says regulators must develop PFAS restrictions before mandating clean-up -Secure Growth Solutions
Wisconsin appeals court says regulators must develop PFAS restrictions before mandating clean-up
View
Date:2025-04-17 20:04:04
Environmental regulators can’t unilaterally force polluters to clean up contamination from so-called forever chemicals without going through the Legislature to establish specific limits on the compounds, a state appellate court ruled Wednesday.
The 2nd District Court of Appeals’ decision all but eliminates the Department of Natural Resources’ authority to unilaterally mandate polluters and landowners report and clean up PFAS contamination in groundwater. If the decision stands, the DNR will now wait for legislators to impose groundwater limits on PFAS through state law or an administrative rule. Both approaches can take years. Environmental advocates also fear that the ruling could slow the DNR’s response to other emerging forms of pollution.
The state Justice Department represented the DNR in the case. Attorney General Josh Kaul said the agency will ask the state Supreme Court to review the decision.
“Safe and clean drinking water shouldn’t be a luxury. It should be accessible to every Wisconsinite,” Kaul said. “This decision would dramatically weaken our ability to protect Wisconsinites from PFAS and other emerging contaminants.”
PFAS, the abbreviation for perfluoroalkyl and polyfluoroalkyl substances, are man-made chemicals that don’t easily break down in nature. They’re found in a wide range of products, including cookware, firefighting foam and stain-resistant clothing. The chemicals have been linked to health problems including low birth weight, cancer and liver disease and have been shown to make vaccines less effective. Communities across Wisconsin are grappling with PFAS contamination, including Marinette, Madison, Eau Claire, La Crosse, Wausau and the towns of Peshtigo and Campbell.
The case in question revolves around Leather Rich, Inc., an Oconomowoc-based dry cleaner. According to court documents, the business learned in 2018 that its property was contaminated with various potentially hazardous substances.
State statutes collectively known as the Spills Law require polluters to notify the DNR of a hazardous discharge and minimize the effect on the environment. Leather Rich was working on clean-up with DNR oversight in early 2019 when the agency posted a message online saying that it now considered PFAS chemicals a hazardous substance under the Spills Law.
The agency ordered the dry cleaner to test its groundwater for PFAS but didn’t tell the business which PFAS compounds it needed to test for — PFAS is a broad term for a group of thousands of different chemicals — or what levels would be considered dangerous.
The dry cleaner along with Wisconsin Manufacturers and Commerce, the state’s largest business group, sued the DNR in 2021. They argued the agency lacked any basis in state law or rules to impose such mandates. The DNR countered that it could unilaterally force testing because the Spills Law gives the agency broad authority to protect the environment.
Waukesha County Circuit Judge Michael Bohren sided with the dry cleaner in 2022, saying the DNR needs to impose limits on PFAS through the rule-making process.
The 2nd District Court of Appeals upheld Bohren, ruling 2-1 that the clean-up mandate is effectively an an administrative rule that was improperly promulgated.
Judge Lisa Neubauer wrote in dissent that state law does not require the DNR to develop rules before the Spills Law can apply.
“Today, for the first time since the statute was enacted, the court holds that the DNR must promulgate rules identifying certain substances as hazardous before the Spills Law applies to discharges of those substances,” Neubauer wrote.
Drafting rules typically takes state agencies years. When the language is settled, the regulations still need legislative approval — a tall task given that Democratic Gov. Tony Evers controls the executive branch and Republicans run the Senate and Assembly.
The DNR’s policy board in February 2022 adopted limits on PFAS in surface and drinking water. The Legislature did not block the standards and they went into effect in June of that year.
The DNR spent most of 2023 working on standards for groundwater, the source of drinking water for about two-thirds of Wisconsin residents.
But Evers said in December the agency had to stop because compliance costs for industrial facilities and wastewater treatment plants that discharge to groundwater were projected at $33 million over the first two years the standards would be in effect. A Republican-authored state law requires state agencies to obtain legislative permission to continue working on regulations that could cost at least $10 million. So far lawmakers haven’t given the DNR the green light to continue.
veryGood! (2)
Related
- American news website Axios laying off dozens of employees
- Rookie Ludvig Aberg makes history with win at RSM Classic, last PGA Tour event of season
- Dissent over US policy in the Israel-Hamas war stirs unusual public protests from federal employees
- Jimmy Johnson to be inducted into Cowboys' Ring of Honor in long-awaited move
- Meet 11-year-old skateboarder Zheng Haohao, the youngest Olympian competing in Paris
- Who is playing in the Big 12 Championship game? A timeline of league's tiebreaker confusion
- Suzanne Shepherd, 'Sopranos' and 'Goodfellas' actress, dies at 89
- Russell Brand interviewed by British police amid claims of sexual assault, reports say
- British swimmer Adam Peaty: There are worms in the food at Paris Olympic Village
- Fires in Brazil threaten jaguars, houses and plants in the world’s largest tropical wetlands
Ranking
- 9/11 hearings at Guantanamo Bay in upheaval after surprise order by US defense chief
- Right-wing populist Milei set to take Argentina down uncharted path: ‘No room for lukewarm measures’
- Palestinians in the West Bank say Israeli settlers attack them, seize their land amid the war with Hamas
- Support pours in after death of former first lady Rosalynn Carter
- Chuck Scarborough signs off: Hoda Kotb, Al Roker tribute legendary New York anchor
- Buffalo Bills safety Taylor Rapp carted off field in ambulance after making tackle
- Inside Former President Jimmy Carter and Wife Rosalynn Carter's 8-Decade Love Story
- Looming volcano eruption in Iceland leaves evacuated small town in limbo: The lava is under our house
Recommendation
NCAA President Charlie Baker would be 'shocked' if women's tournament revenue units isn't passed
3 decades after teen's murder, DNA helps ID killer with a history of crimes against women
Who pulled the trigger? Questions raised after Georgia police officer says his wife fatally shot herself
The Albanian opposition disrupts a Parliament vote on the budget with flares and piled-up chairs
A New York Appellate Court Rejects a Broad Application of the State’s Green Amendment
Donna Kelce Proves Jason and Travis Kelce's Bond Extends Far Beyond Football
Paul Azinger won't return as NBC Sports' lead golf analyst in 2024
Chargers coach Brandon Staley gets heated in postgame exchange after loss to Packers